The #1 Wind energy podcast

Why Blade Repair Records Matter, w/ Rosemary Barnes

Rosemary Barnes, founder of Pardalote Consulting, joins to discuss repair records, serial defects, and blade inspections before a wind farm sale.

The Uptime Wind Energy Podcast is brought to you by Weather Guard Lightning Tech, creators of the StrikeTape Ultra LPS retrofit. Subscribe to Uptime’s Substack newsletter. And check out Rosemary’s “Engineering with Rosie” Youtube channel. Have a question we can answer on the show? Email us!

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] Allen Hall: Wind farms are changing hands at a steady pace, and blades are often the least understood part of the deal. Inspection records are scattered across vendors and years, and the true condition of the fleet can move the price. This week, Rosemary Barnes joins us to discuss how buyers and sellers can get a clear picture of blade health before a deal closes 

Welcome to Uptime Spotlight, shining light on wind energy’s brightest [00:00:30] innovators. This is the progress powering tomorrow 

[00:00:38] Allen Hall: Rosemary, welcome back to the podcast. 

[00:00:40] Rosemary Barnes: Thank you. Nice to be here again, as I am every week. 

[00:00:44] Allen Hall: So you and I were discussing off, uh, camera for the last month or more about transactions at wind farms, uh, of which there has been a number. So when you mentioned it, I went and did a little bit of investigation, and there has been [00:01:00] about 60-odd sales over the past 12 months, which is quite a number, and some big names in there. 

[00:01:07] Rosemary Barnes: We’re talking globally? 

[00:01:09] Allen Hall: Talking globally, yeah. Uh, which in- there’s a lot of transactions happening in Spain. There’s a number in the United States as the repowering situation changed, and production tax credits and the law changed. There was a July 4th deadline, so there was a, the, a number of wind farms exchanging hands, and I, I think globally anyway, just because of the nature of the business, [00:01:30] which brings up this question of what am I buying, what am I selling in terms of blades? And at Pardalote you deal with this quite often because y- especially in Australia, you tend to be in the middle of a lot of, uh, older blades, different blades, unique blades that are being bought and sold. There is a lot to this process, and I, I guess I wanna start off as thinking about the sellers of [00:02:00] what does the seller typically not know about their own blades? ‘Cause that does seem to come up quite a bit when the, the buyer says, “Give me the history of the blades,” and the seller goes, “Uh, I h- I have a, a PDF,” and it’s about five pages thick . It doesn’t feel right for a 100 turbine farm. What don’t they usually know on the sell side? 

[00:02:23] Rosemary Barnes: Yeah. Well, usually, and especially in Australia, these wind farms have full service agreements with the manufacturer, [00:02:30] and so from the owner’s point of view, one of the reasons why they will go that route is that then they don’t have to have the expertise and they don’t have to worry too much about it. You know, they’ve got an availability guarantee, and as long as the service provider is hitting that availability, availability guarantee, they don’t really care too much, um, about how they, how they do it. They’re not trying to micromanage. And then you really have to look to your service agreement to see what kinds of documentation that you’re entitled to, and it varies so [00:03:00] much between agreements. One thing that Pardalote has been doing a fair bit of recently is working with, um, developers that are actually choosing the turbine and, uh, um, yeah, like locking down the, the service agreement. It happens both what, in the process of choosing the manufacturer and then also once they have chosen the manufacturer and they’re just, you know, like actually doing the contract negotiation. It really varies a lot what kinds of documentation you can request or you can, um, you can require [00:03:30] in, yeah, from the service provider. So, you know, the best practice would be that you’re getting every inspection report and access to the online system that they use. It’s really hard to look at, um, PDF inspection reports and figure out anything other than the story that the service provider wants to tell you. Um- Repair reports would be another one. Um, yeah, and then also some of the other things that can be helpful are knowing what are the [00:04:00]manufacturer’s specs for certain things, you know, like, um, resistance of your lightning protection system, other things like that where in theory you can repeat those tests by yourself, but if you don’t know what the criteria is, then you’ve really got no way to interpret your results. So that’s step one is to have re- um, access to those documents in your contracts, um, but that’s only the first step. The second step is actually getting it, and this is where it’s a lot, [00:04:30]um, a lot harder because a lot of the time, you know, asset managers are really busy, and they have a lot of things going on. What they’re not usually doing is chasing up every single inspection report. Do I actually have access to the data? Am I downloading the high-resolution images so that I have them when I need them? Um, because you can– the access to those expires usually after, you know, a few years. Um, making sure, do I have all of the repair reports? That’s a really key one. Uh, do I [00:05:00] know every single repair that’s going on in this site, um, and why? You need all those things for a l- a lot of reasons, not least because you wanna know if you’ve got any serial issues in time to actually address that, um, you know, before your serial defect liability period is up, um, all those sorts of things. But that’s the kind of history that you need to have to know what kind of condition that your blades are in, and I would say it’s not just for if you’re selling the wind farm. That is a really important [00:05:30] time when both sides are gonna wanna know the condition of the blade so that they know, you know, what sort of, um, commitment they’re gonna be looking at to maintain those blades into the future. But there’s a bunch of other, um, situations that can arise in a wind farm’s life where it’s really similar in terms of needing to know the current condition of the blade and kind of like a sale in a lot of ways. So first would be when the, um, full service agreement period is coming up. Um, it’s either it’s ending or it’s coming up for, um, [00:06:00] renewal, so you have to renegotiate the terms of it. Like, if you don’t know the condition of the blades, then you don’t know what that’s worth. You don’t know what the risk is if you choose to go with somebody else. Um, yeah, l- you, you really At that point, you need to know where you stand. Um, also things like lifetime extension, um, yeah, that, that’s another important time to know the condition of your blades. I’ve seen a lot of times they have this lifetime extension [00:06:30]analysis and, um, you know, they’ll go through every single component in the wind farm and say, you know, “Is this a replaceable component? Is it a repairable component?” And I see blades just listed, “Oh, this is a replaceable component.” And it’s like, hmm, yeah, like is it? Uh, you know, it’s not that easy to come by, uh, a new blade, especially for a w- a wind turbine that’s like 20, 25 years old. You know, try buy a brand new blade for that and it’s gonna cost you millions per br- blade probably, um, in Australia at least. 

[00:06:59] Allen Hall: Wh- when a [00:07:00] transaction happens mar宜 . or

Engels 、的天胸

fruition fortn, [00:07:30] ps寄lelീ 女 

[00:07:41] Rosemary Barnes: cockroaches� I in in capit in [00:08:00] in kam am in,ീiori

wes F to, impro,گز in …[00:08:30]

Moe gir ofo in on in eseae ant effect in supplementigung [00:09:00] withначала bilindest in In!

Every asset manager I know is so busy, and are you really gonna spend your time chasing up documentation that you have no [00:09:30] immediate need for, you know, to, to do one of your, you know, top fires that are burning now? It, it’s really, it’s a really hard thing to prioritize, but it is, um, super important that it gets done. 

[00:09:42] Allen Hall: Yeah. I g- I guess I’m wondering what the buyer thinks of that then b- because there is a huge amount of risk here, right? If, if the blades have, uh, leading edge erosion that’s, is deep or some sort of failure mode because of [00:10:00] wind gusts or typhoons, tornadoes, whatever that is, the risk can be rather high in terms of the dollar amount, and I would assume that would want to get negotiated out at the bargaining table to put some numbers around this. With- without having any data at all Doesn’t that he- hurt the seller and also hurt the buyer? It seems like both parties would want to have just a little more data to make this transaction doable. 

[00:10:27] Rosemary Barnes: Yeah, I think so. And I mean, uh, we’ve been thinking about [00:10:30] it from the, the, the owner, current owner, the seller’s point of view in terms of what information that they need to have. But if you think about it from the buyer’s point of view, so for starters, the– it, it would be very reassuring to a potential buyer to just have a stack of this is every single repair that’s happened and why, and this is every single inspection. It’s like when you buy a secondhand car, if they’ve got their full service history in the logbook nicely filled out, then you feel more comfortable with that purchase than if [00:11:00] you, you know, go to buy a secondhand car and it’s just like, “Oh, yeah, I promise it runs really well. I only ever drove it to church on Sundays, and that’s all.” Um, you know, like just trust me, bro, kind of thing is not really gonna make you feel comfortable. However, you’re still gonna wanna do some additional work, and in the absence of all of that kind of data, which I will say that the norm is that you don’t have. Um, like I’ve never worked with a client who just had a full service history for every single wind turbine blade. You know, they don’t, they don’t know [00:11:30] which repairs happened. Um, some of it’s kind of like starts even at the factory level. You know, like they’ll have repairs done in the factory, but they don’t come with a logbook of which repairs were done in, in the factory. The only way that you would get that information is if you’ve got somebody in the factory, um, checking off every single blade as it goes through, um, which by the way, is something that Paddle It can help with if you need somebody to help with your factory acceptance tests. The– A factory visit is a really great way to get a better [00:12:00]understanding of your blade, not just those specific blades and, um, any repairs it might have undergone. But that is your opportunity to build up, uh, some information about what is the blade structure, what are the materials, what kinds of repairs do they do, um, to which areas, what do they look like, um, what is the, you know, design of the lightning protection system Um, yeah, uh, and acceptance criteria for like which, um, which elements of the blade are [00:12:30] important to quality, how are they measured, what are the correct levels? Like all that stuff you might assume you get a blade handbook that has all of that information in it, and you probably do get a blade manual of some sort, but it does not have all that information. And, you know, like I’ve had clients that didn’t even know, does my blade have carbon fiber in it or not? I, I don’t know. There’s like literally not a single mention of any material that’s in this blade anywhere in the package that we’ve been given. It’s the sort of thing that you don’t know until you need that information. So I do [00:13:00] think that, um, that’s something that people don’t, um, utilize. Like nearly every contract will give you the right to do a factory acceptance test and to have a, a presence, um, at the factory. You can go so far as to have someone there for, to see every single blade and see y- y- you know, that, um, every single quality check, um, like, you know, of a certain level. So you can go that far, or you can at least take a few days to go through the whole process of manufacturing and see, you know, some of the, the routine things and, um, [00:13:30] that is something that I don’t, like it sounds like a lot of expense up front. Also, you know, it happens, it, the, it’s one of those difficult situations because it’s for the benefit of operations, but the budget needs to come from, you know, development. So it’s, um, it’s a bit of a mismatch, but that’s definitely one way to, yeah, to build up a good picture of your blade. Anyway, I believe that I s- I got onto that because you were asking about, like, repair history, and I was saying that it’s [00:14:00] not so common that you have the repair history. That’s, you know… Like, we would all wish that. In any case, as a buyer, like, do you trust that they’ve given you e- everything that you need, everything’s accurate, they haven’t missed anything out? And I, I wouldn’t recommend just trusting that. 

[00:14:15] Allen Hall: Well, yeah. What should buyers do to inspect the f- the wind farm in total? It does seem like drone inspections are relatively cheap compared to the price of the wind farm, so it would be [00:14:30] insurance to at least do an exterior drone inspection. The one that always gets, uh, everybody worked up seems to be the internal inspections, because you can see some really significant structural issues internally you probably can’t see on the outside of the blade. Are internal inspections now almost mandatory because, one, because they’re inexpensive, and two, because they really give you a better sense of the health of a blade? 

[00:14:57] Rosemary Barnes: Yeah, I’m not the world’s biggest fan of [00:15:00] internal inspections. For the most part, the internal inspections that I’ve worked with have been mostly false positives, you know, things that look like damages that aren’t. Um, they’re quite hard to interpret just from a blank slate. That said, I would do it if I was buying a, a wind farm. I, uh… ’cause it is not that, um, it, it’s not that expensive to do them, and I think that you can at least screen for systematic things. ‘Cause the things that you really want, like, the things that, uh, I, I would wanna [00:15:30] know about the blades at a site I was buying if I was thinking about buying a wind farm, I would wanna know if there’s any serial issues. Um, and especially, y- you know, like, if you’ve got accelerated fatigue damage, you know, your blades are just wearing out faster, um, than, than they should, then perhaps they’ve just been repaired. It may be that the owner doesn’t even know about it. If the, you know, the full-service provider, if they’re doing their job and just fixing things as they come up and, you know, not really making a big fuss [00:16:00] about it, then you might have, you know, dozens of the same damage that’s just been repaired as they, they came up. But I would want to know about that if, um, if I was a buyer, because you’ll know that into the future probably these blades aren’t gonna last that long or you’ve gotta factor in, you know, a certain amount for repairs. Um, and then other things like how much lightning damage are you seeing? Is that something… Y- you know, there’s a huge difference in, um, how much lightning damage different, different sites and different turbines with [00:16:30] different lightning protection systems. You know, you might be spending 50,000 a year repairing lightning damage, or you might be spending three million a year repairing lightning damage. And if I was a buyer, I would wanna, I would wanna know that. So I would do drone inspections, and I would say that not- Every, like a drone inspection isn’t a drone inspection. You know, some providers have great resolution and you can pick out things like trailing edge cracks that might be an indication that you’ve got a serial defect there. [00:17:00] You can pick out the repair patches, you know. And if you see a lot of, um, repair patches in the same location, it’s like, you know, is this, um, a serial, a serial issue? Does the repair patches… You know, they try and match the color, but it’s always like a little… The shininess is a bit different and, and you can always see, yeah, where there was a repair patch. Um, yeah, so I would recommend getting a full high-resolution drone campaign. The external images is gonna be the most informal th- informative [00:17:30] thing, internal ones also, and then just going through and doing a condition report. That’s one of the main things that we do at Pardalote is we, um, yeah, we will, for existing owners or for buyers, do an initial fleet assessment. Where are your wind turbine blades up to now? Um, and there’s always one or two issues that we can pull out that, you know, hey, this is something that is going to require attention in the near future. Um, we’re also starting to set up [00:18:00] some benchmarking capabilities as well with, um, yeah, with clients who are opting into that. We can tell you, you know, is this an abnormal amount of trailing edge cracks? Is this an abnormal amount of, I don’t know, category five lightning damages? Um, those sorts of things, because they do pop up, and if you’ve only got one or two sites, then you don’t know what to be worried about or what not to be worried about. So it is helpful to be able to compare that to other sites. Also, you know, a site that maybe had a similar problem five years [00:18:30]ago, and we’ve seen over time, hey, you know, this actually isn’t that big a deal. They age pretty well, and they’re pretty easy to repair. You know, that’s information that is good to know. 

[00:18:40] Allen Hall: What do you do about blade bolts, blade inserts, or w- bushings that seem to be problematic on certain turbines? But it does seem, I, I, I will say that there’s one OEM in particular that, that I think about when I say this, but I’ve noticed that it’s happened to a couple of OEMs [00:19:00] How do you even assess the, the blade bolt to the blade connection and is it an ultrasonic scan of some sort just to kind of see what’s going on out there on certain blades? Because the failure mode that is happening more often is not necessarily where the, a blade will break further down its span, it’s right at the blade root. 

[00:19:21] Rosemary Barnes: Yeah. So there’s a few different ways you can approach that, um, and maybe layers depending on what you find at each stage. The first thing that I would do is [00:19:30] find somebody who has experience with that turbine type, that blade type, or at least ones that are similar, ’cause usually, you know, these, um, the turbine manufacturers make things in families and so yeah, the families share certain failure modes in common. So that would be my first step, and that’s not just for blade bolt issues, it’s for anything in the turbine. Like, people that have worked with a few different wind farms with the same turbine type will tell you, “Oh yeah, these things are common on, on this one, and this is what you do about it.” So you need to find somebody that’s got that experience, um, or you [00:20:00] know, find somebody who can find those people. Uh, then if you suspect a problem, then I would be looking for nondestructive testing of a population. I wouldn’t recommend that you just go out and, you know, get somebody on a rope with an ultras- with an ultrasound scanner on every single part of every single blade. That’s gonna be crazy expensive. So you would just do that where you s- you suspected problems, like, you know, has your condition assessment flagged that you’ve got a bunch of repairs [00:20:30] in this zone and some of those repairs are starting to crack themselves now, then that would be a trigger to get up there and maybe scan. Or do you have a whole bunch of trailing edge cracks? Maybe get up there and scan and see, um, you know, is this just some movement in the gel coat that looks like a, a crack or is this an actual crack? And, you know, um, you can extrapolate from that to across your whole fleet. And yeah, the blade bolts would be another issue where you could, um, you can get some early information that way. You can monitor, but I [00:21:00] don’t think that that’s something that you’re going to be doing before your purchase. I’ve never heard of it anyway that– But there are, um, sensors that you can put in place that will monitor for any cracks that are growing or any, like, just sudden change, change in the way that the blades are deflecting and that will, you know, inform if there’s a problem. But yeah, like, I’ve only ever seen that in, um, implemented by owners themselves. I’m not sure that you’d get permission to start whacking sensors on blades that you don’t own [00:21:30] yet. 

[00:21:30] Allen Hall: Well, as a seller though, would sensors make sense in t- in terms of trying to improve the, the price point to put sensors on, particularly for blade bolt issues or blade cracking issues or even gearbox issues for that matter, where you would want to show that everything is pretty much on the up and up, and that it is working like it was intended to work. Sensors give you that sort of independent, uh, second [00:22:00] source to validate, yes, this, this wind farm is working right. Does it make sense to do sensors for the seller a year or so before you try to do the transaction because of that aspect? 

[00:22:12] Rosemary Barnes: I think yes, if you’ve got a known issue, um, you know, people will associate with your turbine type, and people are going to, you know, factor in those kind of problems into their, um, yeah, the amount that they’re prepared to pay. So if you know that you have taken care of an issue, then installing sensors ahead of time to [00:22:30] demonstrate that there is no problem, I think that that would be definitely worthwhile. But also, if you have a turbine with those kinds of issues, then yeah, you should already have been doing that before in order to solve, solve the problem. Hopefully you didn’t just discover that there’s a problem and now you’re trying to sell it without um, communicating to anybody that you have that problem. I hope that that’s, yeah, y- yeah. What’s the, a good used car analogy? But yeah, you know, you’ve already got a, um, I don’t know, [00:23:00] a, a cracked head gasket, but it’ll still turn on and drive around the block without overheating, so, you know, you try and just, just sell it to some idiot. I hope that that’s not happening with wind farm sales, but I guess that that is something to, to be aware of if you’re a buyer. 

[00:23:17] Allen Hall: Well, it, it does seem like there’s, uh, more transaction history going on. There’s, there’s more deep dives into, uh, the wind turbine than I would say five [00:23:30] years ago. Five years ago there was a lot of transactions and it didn’t seem to be a lot of oversight or a review of the data that came along with the wind farm before the sale happened, and that seems to be changing quite rapidly. And I know you at Pardalo are getting involved in a number of those- How soon should someone who’s trying to sell or acquire a wind farm reach out ahead of time to you at Partalo to get a process started? Because it does seem like this is gonna take a couple of [00:24:00] months to, to get everything taken care of. 

[00:24:02] Rosemary Barnes: Yeah. Well, I mean, from the seller’s point of view, the right time to get started is always, you know, like as soon as the project starts, you can, uh, you can end up with a y- you know, a better suited technology to your site if you get involved in the t- um, turbine selection process. So it can start there. Um, obviously you’re not thinking of selling already at that point, or probably not, but I do think that the factory visit is one thing that is, [00:24:30] you know, it’s crazy to me that people aren’t taking advantage of that, um, that requirement that you are allowed into the factory to, you know, understand exactly what you’ve got. Um, yeah, and then I, I guess like for the seller it’s just, y- you know, good asset management to always be aware of, of what your asset is up to. So I think shadow monitoring is really smart, and that would mean that you are always ready for a sale whenever it happened because you always, always know [00:25:00] the history of your, um, yeah, yeah, history of your blades. Then from the buyer’s point of view, I think maybe two different levels. So as soon as you think about buying a site, it would be worth engaging somebody, like Pardalote, um, to just give you a review of what are the known issues with this, um, with this turbine, with this blade type, and to just know what to look out for. You can give a history of, you know, some failures, if they’re publicized around the world [00:25:30] or, you know, there’s also other issues that are kind of known informally. People chat about them at the pub or whatever, but are not writing them down, so not so easy to just do, you know, some desktop searching. So that would be y- you know, your first thing. And then once you’re getting serious about it, then I think you need to get, um, get somebody involved to get some good high-quality inspection images and do a full condition assessment of the fleet and identify if there are any serial issues, [00:26:00] what they are, what the potential solutions would be, and how much they would be likely to cost. I think you definitely need that information to know if you’re buying yourself a headache or if you’re buying yourself a, a good wind farm. 

[00:26:10] Allen Hall: Yeah, so y- it– more than ever, you want to know the status of your wind turbine, and particularly the blades, and you need to hire an expert. That’s why you wanna talk to Pardalote Consulting. Rosemary, how do people get ahold of you to start the process? 

[00:26:26] Rosemary Barnes: They can, uh, find me on LinkedIn is always the easiest [00:26:30] way. If you search Rosemary Barnes, then I am the first one that pops up. Um, yeah, or you can email [email protected]. Or you can, uh, write a comment on the YouTube video as well, and probably Claire, the producer might see it, or or you might. I don’t know. I’m not looking at the comments that often. 

[00:26:50] Allen Hall: Well, this is a good discussion, and I know, uh, a lot of operators that are in the middle of transactions right now and, uh, there’s a lot of back and forth, and it’s good to get everything, uh, out on [00:27:00] the table before you start signing contracts. And Pardalote is a, is a big part of making sure that the records are clean and you know what you’re buying. So Rosemary, this is a really good discussion and, uh, thank you for, for participating in a spotlight episode. 

[00:27:13] Rosemary Barnes: Thank you. I think it is good timing. There’s a few sales that I have heard about at the moment that are ongoing for sites that have had publicized issues with them. So I think that, um, for sure, like I really hope that the potential buyers and sellers are aware of those issues and how to [00:27:30] communicate that they have been adequately taken care of before the sale goes through. So thanks, Allen.

MORE EPISODES

Scroll to Top