The #1 Wind energy podcast

Nordex Loses a Blade, Siemens Gamesa Returns to Profit

Uptime Wind Energy Podcast Logo

Nordex loses a blade during testing in Latvia, Siemens Gamesa returns to profit, and Vestas orders fall 27%. Plus Ørsted earnings climb as injuries rise, and Windcatching lands €100 million.

The Uptime Wind Energy Podcast is brought to you by Weather Guard Lightning Tech, creators of the StrikeTape Ultra LPS retrofit. Subscribe to Uptime’s Substack newsletter. And check out Rosemary’s “Engineering with Rosie” Youtube channel. Have a question we can answer on the show? Email us!

Episode Transcript

Intro and WOMA 2027
Announcer: The Uptime Wind Energy Podcast, brought to you by StrikeTape, protecting thousands of wind turbines from lightning damage worldwide. Visit striketape.com. And now your hosts.
Allen Hall: Welcome to the Uptime Wind Energy Podcast. I’m Allen Hall, and I’m here with Rosemary Barnes, Matthew Stead and Yolanda Padron. To top off the week, you’d better get into WOMA 2027 and get your registration filled out. Get your money sent in, because we’re running out of space. Matthew, there are only 225 seats available, and we’re eating through those pretty quickly at the moment.
Matthew Stead: Yeah, exactly. Get onto the website and register today at WOMA2027.com. It’ll take 30 seconds, I promise you.
Allen Hall: If that. And there are still a couple of sponsor spots available. We’re getting inquiries from around the world, so those are becoming limited. If you want to do something at WOMA 2027, I encourage you to do that. Matthew, where would they go?
Matthew Stead: WOMA2027.com.
Vestas, Siemens Gamesa and Windcatching
Allen Hall: There’s been a bunch of news coming from Vestas and Siemens Gamesa in the last 24 to 48 hours, and it’s good. Vestas just had a pretty good time of it. They raised revenue to €5.7 billion. That’s a lot of euros. Orders fell 27%, though, which appears to be in response to the He Dreiht blade issue that happened a couple of months ago, back in July, I think.
Meanwhile, Siemens Gamesa made a return to profit. Remember when Siemens Gamesa ran into trouble a couple of years ago? They were hoping to be back on track in 2025 or 2026. So they’ve done it, but they only made €8 million of profit. They’re barely profitable, but hey, it’s a start.
Both Vestas and Siemens Gamesa are really hoping to be big in offshore wind. This is going to be the driver, just because of the size of the turbines. They’re massive, 15 megawatts and up, and if you listen to Siemens Gamesa, they’re talking about a 20-megawatt-plus machine. Is this the path forward? Is the momentum going to swing away from onshore wind to offshore, just because that’s where the focus is at the moment?
Rosemary Barnes: It’s the main part of the industry that’s going well at the moment. It’s the main good news story in the industry, but it’s not here yet in Australia, and it’s pretty much not there in the US either. I don’t think it’s the right strategy to focus on offshore to the exclusion of all others. It definitely makes sense, since that’s where the profits are coming from at the moment. But I do hope they’re still going to be improving onshore technologies alongside that.
Matthew Stead: I agree with Rosie. I don’t really see offshore wind in Australia any time soon. All the regulatory processes just take forever, and onshore is way, way faster and easier to build. Although, can I throw something back there? If we start talking about 20 megawatts, do you still actually need to build a whole wind farm? Because they’re so large, maybe you can just build one wind turbine, and that’s your power plant, and get away from some of these other problems.
Rosemary Barnes: With offshore, the economics really do rely on it being a huge wind farm. There’s so much work that needs to be done and so much new infrastructure, not just in the wind farm, but also in getting the components onto ships and out to site, all that sort of thing. I don’t think it’s ever going to stack up for a single turbine. So I don’t think we’ll be seeing 20-megawatt offshore wind farms with a single turbine in them any time soon.
Allen Hall: Rosemary, you’ve been working with the company that’s talking about building a wall of wind turbines. It looks like they got some funding up in Norway, which is a good sign.
Rosemary Barnes: We’re talking about Windcatching. I haven’t been working with them. I’ve consistently tried to indicate that I had good ideas for them, and I would love to work with them, but it’s never led to any real inroads. I’ve seen that they’ve got, what did you say it was, €100 million?
Allen Hall: It was about €100 million they were funded with, which is a tremendous amount of money.
Rosemary Barnes: That’s a lot of money. I don’t think it’s enough to build a first-of-a-kind offshore wind turbine of that size, though. This is not something they’ve already built onshore, where it’s just a matter of replacing some of the materials with a higher grade of stainless steel, putting in some better seals and attaching it to a subsea foundation. It’s a whole new, huge turbine that’s different to anything that’s ever been made before.
I’m not in the loop, so I don’t know what their development has involved. But I’ve never seen reporting that they’ve built a smaller-scale grid of these turbines onshore.
I guess we should describe the concept, because not everyone’s going to be familiar. The Windcatching system is a grid of small wind turbines. At one point they were going to be two-bladed. I think the latest renderings have three blades, which was one of my early comments: don’t change anything you don’t have to. You’re going to have so many new ways this will break that have never been seen before in any existing wind turbine. You don’t need to invent new surprises. So that’s one sensible decision.
By having a grid of small turbines instead of a large single rotor, there are definitely some advantages. First of all, aerodynamically it’s a bit more efficient to put rotors next to each other. You get this multi-rotor effect, and it’s been pretty well studied, including with some real turbines. Vestas, I believe, in the early days put four rotors together and measured improved aerodynamics compared to one big rotor of the same size, or four separate ones. So that’s real.
Additionally, if you’ve got a single wall of wind turbines, you don’t have to worry about wake effects. If you had all of those individual turbines out separately, depending on the wind direction, some of them would be in the wake of others, and you would lose some efficiency. When they’re all on the same structure, they’re all yawing together, and no turbine will ever be in another’s wake.
Allen Hall: Do you think Siemens Gamesa or Vestas will get involved in one of these projects? That’s part one. Part two: if you’re going to put up a Windcatching system, why would you not put up multiples of them? It seems like some finance person would want to put as many of these in the water as they possibly could, in some sort of wind-maximizing scheme.
Rosemary Barnes: It’s an interesting development challenge. In terms of the engineering, you want to be making the smallest increments you can, so that you have a mostly successful trial with a few things learned. What you don’t want is for it to categorically fail, so badly that you didn’t even get a chance to test many of the things you were trying to test. You want a small change at a time.
However, that’s really incompatible with the way most projects are funded. Most investors want to see you moving up the technology readiness levels as fast as possible. They want to see something that’s been in the ocean, in its real operating environment. That’s what’s going to unlock the next round of funding. If they did anything less than that, they would probably really struggle to raise additional funding, based on the reduction in risk.
It’s a big bet, and a lot of things need to go their way for this to pay off. I always appreciate a bold move. I do think Windcatching is an overall good concept, and I’m definitely in the minority of wind energy experts on that. But I think the most likely outcome is poor execution of a good concept, and that just kills the concept forever. That’s the big risk.
Allen Hall: How much money do you think they really need to get into production?
Rosemary Barnes: I don’t know. All I can base it on is my own experience with project budgets for the kinds of systems I’ve worked on. €5 million or €10 million was not a huge project. That was not a game-changing technology I would develop with a budget like that. If this is, say, 100 times more ambitious, and that’s a conservative estimate, 100 times harder than making a new kind of de-icing system, then I think 5 or 10 times more money would be the minimum you’d need to try. Hopefully they’ve got that.
Allen Hall: They may.
Rosemary Barnes: Maybe there’s an interested and patient billionaire waiting in the wings to give them money to replace their cables and blades when they break. I hope so, because I think that’s what they’re going to need for this to be a successful prototype.
Allen Hall: Well, that’s Vestas and Siemens Gamesa.
Sponsor messages
Announcer: Are you overspending on lightning repairs? Most operators are, because solving lightning damage is complicated. Weather Guard Lightning Tech helps operators reduce lightning damage. Our innovative StrikeTape lightning diverter protects over 20,000 blades worldwide. Now StrikeTape Ultra installs faster than ever, curing up-tower in just 15 minutes, even in cold weather. Visit weatherguardwind.com to schedule a call.
Allen Hall: Hey everyone, it’s Allen from the Uptime podcast. Join me March 3rd through the 5th in Melbourne for Wind O&M Australia 2027. We’ll be discussing topics like blade inspections and repairs, robots and AI, rotating equipment, OEM upgrades, life extension and cybersecurity. And new this year, Rosemary is giving a blades masterclass, which is free with general admission. This conference is focused on solutions, not speeches. So register now at WindOMAustralia.com, and I’ll see you in Melbourne.
Ørsted earnings and safety
Allen Hall: Ørsted has good news and bad news this quarter. Earnings are up 19% for the first nine months, and that’s a huge win for Ørsted. But its injury rate is the highest since 2020, and the rise is sharpest among its own staff. Ørsted declined to answer some questions from EnergyWatch at the press briefing.
It does say that a lot of the safety issues they’re having are relatively minor, at least that’s what’s being said at the moment. But I know the culture at Ørsted is to provide as much safety training as they can. Anybody who’s been around them at all realizes that, being Danish, safety is part of the culture there. Still, it’s a good sign to see Ørsted increasing its earnings. Yolanda, that hasn’t happened for a couple of years. Maybe they’re over the US offshore shock?
Yolanda Padron: Yeah, I think so. It’s really good to see them doing well. Part of their safety culture, and something everybody should implement but not everybody does, is that they try to flag every single incident. Internally they have that culture of “tell us anything that happens, don’t try to cover anything up.” They don’t even have the signs most buildings have, like “zero accidents in three days,” because that discourages people from going in and flagging what’s happening. Then all of those small errors turn into something bigger. So honestly, the fact that they’re reporting more incidents is good.
They also went through a lot of layoffs in the past few years. That changes the percentage of people who are on site, because you’re changing the denominator of hours on site. So I’m curious to see whether the rate changed among the people on site, or whether it was a big company-wide thing.
Allen Hall: You see that in several industries when there’s an influx or outflow of people. Safety isn’t built into every person who joins the company, so it takes time for everybody to get on board with what’s happening safety-wise. I would assume Ørsted knew that and has been trying to mitigate it as much as they can.
From the financial standpoint, their EBITDA rose 19%. That’s a huge number. It seems they offloaded some of the less profitable projects they were involved with. They’ve offloaded most of their onshore fleet, except in the United States, which I think is fascinating, because that would seem like the obvious one to try to get off the books.
Yolanda Padron: Yeah. And Ørsted’s onshore fleet is pretty homogeneous, too, so it’s relatively easy to manage compared to some of the other owner-operators we’ve seen that have a mix of everything and have to deal with 13 different blade types. So yeah, it’s good to see them doing well.
Nordex blade failure in Latvia
Allen Hall: Nordex spent the past year filling out its order book, which is great. Now it has to get the turbines to site. Third-quarter EBIT more than doubled, and guidance actually went up. But the CEO of Nordex has flagged limits on moving oversize parts. And just recently in Latvia, Nordex lost a blade during one of its test runs.
Rosemary, I slacked you when I saw that first news report about the Latvia turbine. It seems to be the only thing slowing Nordex down at the minute. Is it normal to have blades fail like that when you’re running tests? The whole thing just seemed a little crazy.
Rosemary Barnes: It’s funny. It’s something we’ve seen a lot in the Chinese media, where prototypes have had blades fail. I’ve been interested in the commentary. There was one from Ming Yang, and the company’s response was, in my opinion, hilarious. They said, “Oh, it was just a really big gust of wind. Who could have foreseen that? That’s what prototypes are for.” And that’s not what prototypes are for, because a blade breaking on a turbine is a huge safety risk.
Other than the turbine burning down or the whole turbine falling down, a blade being liberated, which is the industry euphemism for a blade falling off, is the third most catastrophic thing that can happen. People work in and around these turbines, so it’s a big safety issue. Nobody installs a prototype with the intent of a blade falling off.
If it does happen, then maybe it was a really big gust of wind, and the takeaway is that you’re really bad at site selection. Or there’s a gap in understanding how real loads are going to be applied to your blade. You can calculate a load, but the way you apply it to your test blade doesn’t really reflect how blades are loaded in reality. So there might be a mismatch between your design process and real operating conditions.
The other possibility is that your blade is just not good enough. That could be a design issue, which I would say is usually the case. When you see all three blades on a prototype turbine break off, it’s like, okay, this one’s just not strong enough. But with a single blade, it could be a design issue, or it could be a manufacturing issue, and it could be a one-off.
I work on several cases every year where a blade has broken off a turbine type that has thousands of units worldwide. It’s not that those blades are all made wrong or designed wrong. It’s a combination of factors that leads to a catastrophic failure. When it happens early on a prototype, it’s a lot easier to say it’s a design issue. When you’ve got thousands of turbines that aren’t dropping blades all the time, you know for sure it’s not a major design issue. But when it’s your first turbine, you also have to ask whether it saw extreme operating conditions. I didn’t hear about any kind of extreme storm, like a 1-in-100-year storm or anything.
Allen Hall: [Crosstalk]
Rosemary Barnes: But it’s bad news, because obviously that test is not passed, and they’re not just going to move on. Usually when you roll out a new platform, you’ve done your test blade, you’ve put your prototype up, and you’ve got blades already rolling off the production line, not to mention all the other turbine components.
If it ends up being a design issue, it will usually be something simple, like “we need one more ply in this location” or “this ply needs to extend further.” Even in that best case, they’d have to go back and do that to every single blade they’ve already made. That’s a lot. It happens from time to time, and it’s certainly not unprecedented. Every manufacturer has gone through that at some point.
The other thing it could be is a manufacturing defect. Was it a one-off? Sometimes I might drop a pen into the glass fabrics and not notice. That’s a foreign object contamination defect. It happens. Or it could have been some other one-off thing that wasn’t caught early. That’s probably the best case scenario: that blade was bad, but we don’t have to change anything.
Worse than that, there could be a serial manufacturing issue that’s not so easy to solve. Sometimes you just can’t infuse a certain blade shape reliably and with high quality, and you get air voids. Or their usual quality control process doesn’t catch this particular new kind of defect. That would probably be their nightmare scenario, because then they have to figure out how to fix it.
It’s like fixing the airplane while it’s flying. They don’t want to stop blades rolling off the production line, because they’ve presumably got sales for them. But they also don’t want to keep making blades with defects they’ll have to go back and fix. So it could be anywhere on that spectrum, from one badly made blade that gets replaced, to every blade needing a fix and a design change. There’s no way for a podcaster to know where in that spectrum it fits without some site-specific information.
Allen Hall: One of my questions at the time was whether it was just a controls issue, where the turbine controls were not set up properly or something odd happened so the turbine was put in a compromised mode. That’s what it would seem like at the moment. There’s so much work going into making blades and making them reliable. Nordex, at least historically from my recollection, has made good-quality products and been really on top of issues early. If they have issues in the field, they’re going to react with a tremendous amount of force and effort to get it resolved. So it does raise the question of how some of these tests get run, and how a blade ends up compromised. There’s a lot to a wind turbine today, a lot more than there used to be.
Matthew Stead: I wanted to raise maybe a bit of a sleeper problem: transportation. There’s always a possibility of damage during transportation. I’m not sure whether an internal inspection would have been carried out, or whether it would have caught transportation damage. When I’ve thought about blade failures, transportation is sometimes one of the topics. That was my initial thought.
The other thing is, I was doing some work recently on the various resonances of blades and towers. Some of the different modes might coincide with your rotational speed. So, like you said, going back to the control system, there’s the question of whether a resonance is being excited or not.
This is really boring, but I was reading one of the IEC standards the other day, and I was surprised by the amount of variation allowed from the design model. There’s a design model for the modal behavior and so on, and when you test, there’s an allowed variance from it. So the stiffness doesn’t have to be exactly as predicted, and the natural frequencies don’t have to be exactly as predicted. I’m wondering whether sometimes the natural or resonant frequencies might differ from the design, and the control design might then need to be different. So, resonance. Just a thought.
Allen Hall: Well, we know that to be true on some of the blades manufactured by the US OEM. They’ve had resonances on blades. So they must have miscalculated, or made changes going through the production process, where a blade that was okay all of a sudden changed. Yolanda, you’ve seen some of those blades. It was a big deal in the United States for probably two years or more.
Yolanda Padron: There are so many factors that can go into it. Like Rosie said, and Matthew touched on it too, you can have the exact same blade model and just have it manufactured in a different factory, or even in the same factory at a different point in time, and the process can look different based on who was there at the moment. If someone put something in the blade they really weren’t supposed to, and I don’t mean anything malicious, it’s just someone who didn’t know they weren’t supposed to be doing what they were doing, then that causes a lot of issues down the line.
Things left behind in blades
Allen Hall: So someone explain to me, because I’ve seen this on aircraft quite a bit, speaking of odd things: why do technicians leave tools behind?
Yolanda Padron: Exactly.
Rosemary Barnes: I heard of someone at LM, I can’t remember who it was, but there was a story about the weirdest thing anyone ever found in a wind turbine. The weirdest one was a pair of pants.
Yolanda Padron: How do you even…
Rosemary Barnes: They do leave things behind that you would think would be valuable.
Matthew Stead: But this is going to be really uncomfortable if you haven’t got any pants on and you’re coming down.
Yolanda Padron: Could you imagine?
Allen Hall: For safety, that’s one of the things you need.
Matthew Stead: That’s an incident. Definitely an incident.
Allen Hall: I’ve seen pictures of scissors in blades, which I guess makes sense. You’re probably using scissors to cut plies, and they end up in a wind turbine. But a pair of pants? That’s a new one, Rosemary.
Rosemary Barnes: I’m personally responsible for multiple pens being left in blades, pens that you write with. I want to say I’ve never dropped a screwdriver or a spanner in a blade, but I don’t know. I know I’ve definitely dropped tools. You can drop something down onto the deck, and there are places where you can’t retrieve things. I’ve certainly dropped tools in there.
Yolanda Padron: Well, that’s a fair point. For those of us who mostly just look at images of the damage after the fact and aren’t climbing every single day, it seems like it would be a lot harder to make that mistake than it probably is.
Closing
Allen Hall: Well, that wraps up another episode of the Uptime Wind Energy Podcast. If today’s discussion sparked any questions or ideas, we’d love to hear from you. Reach out to us on LinkedIn or email us at [email protected]. And if you found value in today’s conversation, please leave us a review. It really helps other wind energy professionals discover the show. And don’t forget to subscribe, particularly on YouTube, so you never miss an episode. For Rosie, Yolanda and Matthew, I’m Allen Hall, and we’ll see you here next week on the Uptime Wind Energy Podcast.

MORE EPISODES

Scroll to Top